Science in Support of Health Insurance Reform
A study recently published in the journal Cancer Epidemiology, Biomarkers, and Prevention found that insurance status is strongly associated with disease severity of prostate cancer in men between the ages of 18 and 99 years. The study examined a large cohort of men from the National Cancer Database, 2004-2006. Importantly, results showed that lack of insurance is significantly associated with more advanced disease at diagnosis, even when race and socioeconomic status are controlled. The relationship held for both men less than and older than 65 years. The authors conclude
In a large national sample of men diagnosed with prostate cancer in 2004-2006, we found that men who were uninsured or Medicaid insured at the time of diagnosis had significantly higher PSA [prostate specific antigen] levels, clinical T stage, and Gleason scores than men with private insurance. Greater disease severity among men who are uninsured or Medicaid insured likely reflects lower access to medical care and utilization of PSA testing and a higher proportion of non–screen-detected cancers.
The findings suggest that Medicaid insurance may not be effectively covering patients. In this study, Medicaid was less “protective” than private insurance. The authors speculate that enrollment times may account for some of this discrepancy.
Increased disease severity among patients coded as insured by Medicaid may be due in part to retroactive enrollment of uninsured individuals after their cancer diagnosis, and may not reflect access to care among persons continuously insured by Medicaid.
For those whose concern is limited to economic factors, the study might be taken further to calculate the costs to the medical system of those more advanced disease patients compared to those diagnosed at earlier stages.
Source: Fedewa et al, Association of Insurance and Race/Ethnicity with Disease Severity Among Men Diagnosed with Prostate Cancer, National Cancer Database, 2004-2006, Cancer Epidemiology, Biomarkers, and Prevention, 2010, 19: 2437-44.

Recent Comments